ログイン
言語:

WEKO3

  • トップ
  • ランキング
To
lat lon distance
To

Field does not validate



インデックスリンク

インデックスツリー

メールアドレスを入力してください。

WEKO

One fine body…

WEKO

One fine body…

アイテム

  1. 114 人文社会系研究科・文学部
  2. 10 宗教学・宗教史学研究室
  3. 東京大学宗教学年報
  4. 30
  1. 0 資料タイプ別
  2. 30 紀要・部局刊行物
  3. 東京大学宗教学年報
  4. 30

宗教学的生命倫理研究のための素描・続 : エンゲルハートと聶精保の対比を軸に

http://hdl.handle.net/2261/55323
http://hdl.handle.net/2261/55323
2a314d90-b186-4b97-9788-46005aa210e3
名前 / ファイル ライセンス アクション
rel030001.pdf rel030001.pdf (1.1 MB)
Item type 紀要論文 / Departmental Bulletin Paper(1)
公開日 2013-08-20
タイトル
タイトル 宗教学的生命倫理研究のための素描・続 : エンゲルハートと聶精保の対比を軸に
言語
言語 jpn
資源タイプ
資源 http://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_6501
タイプ departmental bulletin paper
その他のタイトル
その他のタイトル Rethiking Bioethics from the Viewpoint of Religious Studies : Comparison between Engelhardt and Nie Qingbao
著者 池澤, 優

× 池澤, 優

WEKO 66774

池澤, 優

Search repository
著者別名
識別子Scheme WEKO
識別子 66775
姓名 Ikezawa, Masaru
著者所属
著者所属 東京大学
抄録
内容記述タイプ Abstract
内容記述 The author published two articles concerning Bioethics in this magazine in 2006 and 2007. The present article discusses the same problem: constructing Bioethical studies from the viewpoint of religious studies. The main theme is the relationships between bioethical discourses and religious traditions. This article deals with two recently published books in the field of Bioethics: Tristram Engelhardt's The Foundation of Christian Bioethics (Swets & Zeitlinger Publishers, 2000) and Nie JingBao's Medical Ethics in China: a Transcultural Interpretation (Routledge, 2011). Nie Qingbao criticizes Engelhardt's assertion of "Christian Bioethics," and advocates "Transcultural Bioethics." His main concern lies in comparison of cultures. Engelhardt's assertion is based on his understanding of the postmodern world as a "libertarian cosmopolis," in which various communities co-exist without sharing any basic value systems. In such a situation, the only possible foundation of ethics is free and voluntary agreements, and "moral strangers" who do not share any moral views cooperate on the basis of agreements. This is what he calls "empty framework" or "content-less ethics." But this "empty framework" cannot be actually empty. Agreements signify a value: the value of autonomy and self-determination. The "empty framework" forces the various communities to accept this value. Engelhardt tries to protect the Christian values and worldviews against this secular value. Nie Jingbao criticizes Engelhardt's basic premise that various communities in the secular world cannot share any value systems. If Engelhardt's premise is correct, it means that all cultures are "radical others" and totally incommensurable. But this premise conflicts with our matter-of-fact perception of cross-cultural commonalities or shared humanity. Nie Jingbao argues that the "radical others" view over-simplifies cultural differences, and ignores the internal plurality in a culture. He calls this view as "the fallacy of dichotomizing cultures," which is dangerous in practice, because conservative governors try to justify the existing social structures, by the way of appealing to cultural differences. It seems that Engelhardt and Nie Jingbao discuss the different levels of cultural differences. Nie Jingbao points to the "real" differences, including similarities, while Engelhardt asserts the ''constractive''creation of such differences. The latter's strategy is possible and even necessary, but we need to recognize that it is not "real" but "constructive," because it always includes simplification and distortion.
内容記述
内容記述タイプ Other
内容記述 論文/Articles
書誌情報 東京大学宗教学年報

巻 30, p. 1-15, 発行日 2013-03-31
ISSN
収録物識別子タイプ ISSN
収録物識別子 02896400
書誌レコードID
収録物識別子タイプ NCID
収録物識別子 AN10032645
出版者
出版者 東京大学文学部宗教学研究室
出版者別名
Department of Religious Studies. The University of Tokyo
戻る
0
views
See details
Views

Versions

Ver.1 2021-03-02 02:57:27.046876
Show All versions

Share

Mendeley Twitter Facebook Print Addthis

Cite as

エクスポート

OAI-PMH
  • OAI-PMH JPCOAR 2.0
  • OAI-PMH JPCOAR 1.0
  • OAI-PMH DublinCore
  • OAI-PMH DDI
Other Formats
  • JSON
  • BIBTEX

Confirm


Powered by WEKO3


Powered by WEKO3